Merissa Sherrill Lynn, the founder of The Tiffany Club, became a member of the Cherrystone Club in 1975. Three years later, due to internal dissension regarding the nature and future course of the Cross-dressing and the emerging Transsexual communities, the Cherrystone Club split into two factions; those who felt it should be a strictly social group, and those who wanted it to be a support group. The social group, led by Kay Campbell, became the Kay Mayflower Society.
They moved their operations to 65 Chester Street, Allston, Massachusetts. This group gradually evolved into an Alternate Lifestyle club. Their operations phased out in 1985.